No One Expected Him to Become Pope: The Untold Story of How Robert Prevost Became Leo XIV
No One Expected Him to Become Pope: The Untold Story of How Robert Prevost Became Leo XIV
When white smoke rose above the Vatican on May 8, 2025, millions of people around the world waited to discover who would become the next leader of the Catholic Church. The announcement surprised many observers: Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost, a Chicago-born Augustinian missionary who had spent much of his adult life in Peru, had been elected Pope Leo XIV.
But according to a new biography, American Pope: Leo XIV’s Road from the South Side of Chicago to Vatican City, written by NPR journalists Scott Detrow and Daniel Burke, the man himself was among those least convinced that such an outcome was possible.
In an excerpt and accompanying interview published by NPR on October 3, 2026, the authors revealed personal stories, private messages and recollections from people who had known Prevost long before he became one of the most recognizable religious figures in the world.
The book describes a man whose election seemed unlikely for several reasons. He was American, relatively unknown to many cardinals outside the circles in which he had worked, and had spent decades serving far from the political and ecclesiastical spotlight of Rome.
A future pope who thought an American would never be elected
Before the conclave began, Prevost reportedly told a close friend that there would not be an American pope and that he was sleeping well at night.
His confidence reflected a widely held assumption among Church observers. The United States already possessed considerable political, economic and military influence around the world, and some believed electing an American pope could create complications for the Vatican’s international position.
Cardinal Blase Cupich of Chicago had also publicly expressed doubts about the prudence of electing someone from such a powerful country. Prevost read the comments and repeated the conclusion to his friend Father John Merkelis.
However, when Merkelis shared the remark with Sister Thérèse DelGenio, a longtime friend and mentor, she responded with a memorable observation: he had forgotten about the Holy Spirit.
The exchange became one of the more revealing stories in the biography. While people close to Prevost could recognize his qualities, he apparently did not see himself as a likely candidate for the papacy.
Friends saw something others had overlooked
The book also recounts messages Prevost received after Pope Francis died. Friends from different stages of his life contacted him to offer condolences and prayers.
One of them was John Barry, a friend dating back to high school. Barry told Prevost that he believed he could become the next pope and that his compassion, intelligence and character made him suitable for the responsibility.
Prevost responded that he was leaving everything in the Lord’s hands. Even as the possibility of becoming pope was being discussed, he remained focused on the death of Francis and the uncertainty facing the Church.
Another longtime friend, Lutheran pastor John Snider, had known Prevost decades earlier. The two had spent time discussing theology and learning how to minister to people who were sick or approaching the end of life. Their friendship continued over the years, despite their different religious traditions and professional paths.
These personal relationships helped the authors portray Prevost as someone whose life was shaped by ordinary friendships as much as by his religious responsibilities.
A bishop who preferred a pickup truck to a formal entrance
One of the most striking aspects of the biography concerns Prevost’s practical approach to leadership in Peru.
During his years there, communities experienced serious flooding and other natural disasters. The book recounts an occasion when a Church charity organization was responding to flooding and Prevost arrived in a pickup truck loaded with food for distribution.
A woman involved in organizing the relief effort reportedly said she had worked with several bishops but had never seen one arrive personally in a pickup truck carrying supplies.
Another story describes what happened when a parish ran out of palm branches shortly before Palm Sunday. Rather than simply asking someone else to solve the problem, Prevost reportedly took a machete, went to a nearby palm tree and cut down branches for the congregation.
These accounts illustrate the practical attitude that people who worked with him came to recognize. He was willing to perform ordinary tasks when he saw something that needed to be done.
According to Detrow, Prevost was not a micromanager, but he did not hesitate to get involved when a situation required immediate action.
That approach would later become one of the defining elements of his reputation as a bishop and Church administrator.
Why Peru changed his understanding of poverty and migration
The biography also explores the influence of Prevost’s missionary years on his views about migration.
When he served as bishop in Peru, the country experienced a major influx of Venezuelan migrants fleeing political instability and economic hardship. Millions of people across the region were affected by the crisis, and many arrived in Peru seeking safety and a better future.
Prevost supported efforts to provide migrants with housing, food and other assistance. Detrow recalled that the bishop sometimes visited food distribution centers and sat at tables with Venezuelan migrants to share meals.
The gesture was important because it communicated that migrants were not outsiders to be viewed from a distance. They were people whose dignity deserved recognition and whose circumstances required a compassionate response.
The authors believe these experiences help explain why immigration has remained an important concern for Leo XIV.
Although Prevost often tried to avoid being identified with a particular political party during his years in Peru, he was willing to speak about issues that affected vulnerable people. His approach was rooted in his understanding of the Gospel rather than in a desire to participate in partisan political disputes.
The man behind the historic election
The NPR report presents a portrait of a future pope who did not build his career around expectations of power. Instead, his life developed through missionary service, friendships, practical responsibilities and years of working among communities facing difficult circumstances.
His election on May 8, 2025, therefore represented a historic moment not only because he became the first American-born pope, but also because his personal journey crossed national and cultural boundaries.
The biography, American Pope, seeks to explain how a man known to friends simply as Bob eventually became Leo XIV. Its stories suggest that the qualities that brought him to the Vatican were already visible long before the white smoke appeared above St. Peter’s Square.
Source: NPR; NPR Illinois; WLRN