PART 2 — THE ILLNESS THAT RETURNED

PART 2 — THE ILLNESS THAT RETURNED
For several seconds, nobody moved.

The cellar lantern cast a trembling circle of light across the stone floor.

Nathaniel stood with one hand against the wooden staircase, staring at the receipt in Evelyn’s fingers.

“Eliza was sick?” he whispered.

Beatrice’s face tightened.

“Of course she was sick. You know that.”

“You told me it was her heart.”

“It was.”

“Then why does this say abdominal illness?”

Beatrice looked away.

Evelyn studied the faded handwriting.

The receipt had been issued by a physician in Cheyenne, not the traveling doctor Beatrice had mentioned earlier.

There was a date.

A list of medicines.

And a note written beneath the charges.

Patient reports persistent pain and swelling. Further examination strongly recommended.

Evelyn read the words aloud.

Nathaniel closed his eyes.

He remembered Eliza’s final months.

Her exhaustion.

The way she sometimes pressed a hand against her stomach while preparing supper.

The meals she stopped eating.

The afternoons she spent lying in bed.

He had believed her when she said it was nothing.

Or perhaps he had simply wanted to believe her.

“Why didn’t you tell me?” he whispered.

Beatrice lifted her chin.

“Because Eliza asked me not to.”

Nathaniel looked at her.

“Why would she do that?”

“She didn’t want you worrying.”

Evelyn felt a flicker of uncertainty.

That explanation was possible.

People sometimes concealed illnesses from those they loved.

But something about Beatrice’s urgency troubled her.

“Where are the rest of Eliza’s medical papers?” Evelyn asked.

Beatrice stared at her.

“You have no right to go through my sister’s belongings.”

“Then Nathaniel can ask.”

Nathaniel stepped forward.

“Where are they, Beatrice?”

Her shoulders sagged.

“In the trunk.”

“Which trunk?”

“The cedar one in the attic.”

Nathaniel turned toward the stairs.

“Then we’re going to look.”

The attic smelled of dry wood, dust, and old lavender.

Moonlight filtered through a small window.

Against the far wall stood a cedar trunk with brass corners.

Nathaniel knelt beside it.

He hesitated before opening the lid.

Evelyn understood.

Inside were the remains of a life he had loved and lost.

A folded wedding dress.

A blue ribbon.

A bundle of letters tied with string.

A tiny pair of baby shoes.

Nathaniel lifted the shoes carefully.

“Grace wore these.”

His voice broke.

Evelyn looked away, giving him a moment.

Beneath the clothing lay a leather folder.

Nathaniel opened it.

Inside were receipts, prescriptions, and several letters.

One envelope had been addressed to Eliza from a physician in Cheyenne.

It had never been opened.

Nathaniel stared at the seal.

“She never told me about this.”

Evelyn said nothing.

He broke the seal.

The letter was brief.

Doctor Samuel Warren expressed concern that Eliza’s condition had continued despite treatment. He advised immediate examination at a larger medical facility and specifically warned against relying on patent medicines of uncertain composition.

Nathaniel read it twice.

Then he handed it to Evelyn.

“She was taking something?”

“Perhaps.”

He looked toward the attic door.

“Beatrice was helping her then.”

Evelyn folded the letter carefully.

“We don’t know what happened yet.”

Nathaniel nodded, though the fear in his eyes deepened.

The following morning, Doctor Rowan arrived shortly after sunrise.

He was a silver-haired physician with a worn black medical bag and a manner that suggested he had seen more suffering than he cared to remember.

Walter had ridden through much of the night to bring him.

Nathaniel met the doctor on the porch.

“She’s worse,” he said.

Rowan looked at Evelyn.

“And you are?”

“Evelyn Hart.”

“She has been helping Grace,” Nathaniel explained.

Rowan nodded and went directly to the bedroom.

He examined Grace carefully.

He listened to her breathing, checked her pulse, asked her about the pain, and gently examined her swollen abdomen.

Evelyn remained nearby.

Beatrice stood in the doorway.

When the examination ended, the doctor’s expression was grave.

“She’s badly weakened,” he said. “And the swelling requires proper investigation.”

Nathaniel swallowed.

“Can you help her?”

“I’ll do everything I can.”

He looked toward Beatrice.

“What medicines has she been receiving?”

Beatrice stepped forward.

“A tonic prescribed by Doctor Sloane.”

“May I see it?”

Beatrice hesitated.

Evelyn watched her carefully.

“I believe it’s been misplaced,” Beatrice answered.

Nathaniel turned sharply.

“Misplaced?”

“I put it away.”

“Where?”

Beatrice’s eyes moved toward Evelyn.

“I don’t remember.”

Doctor Rowan’s expression changed.

“Miss Beatrice, this is important.”

“I’m not Mrs. Cole,” she snapped.

The doctor remained calm.

“Then Miss Beatrice, please understand that an unidentified preparation may complicate a child’s illness. I need to know what she has been given.”

Beatrice pressed her lips together.

Evelyn spoke.

“We found empty bottles in the cellar.”

Rowan looked at her.

“Can you bring them?”

Nathaniel went downstairs.

He returned with three bottles wrapped in cloth.

The physician examined them.

He removed the cork from one and carefully inspected the residue.

His brows drew together.

“Where did these come from?”

Beatrice said nothing.

Rowan looked at Nathaniel.

“I cannot identify the contents by appearance or smell. These must be preserved for proper examination.”

“Do you think she’s been poisoned?” Nathaniel asked.

The doctor hesitated.

“We must consider every possibility. But her symptoms alone cannot establish the cause.”

Evelyn appreciated his caution.

Fear was already spreading through the house.

They needed evidence, not accusations.

Doctor Rowan instructed them to stop giving Grace the unidentified tonic and to follow his directions for food, fluids, and further examination.

He promised to return with additional supplies and arrange a more thorough evaluation.

Before leaving, he drew Nathaniel aside.

Evelyn could not hear everything.

But she heard one sentence clearly.

“If this has been happening for months, we need to understand why no one sought another medical opinion sooner.”

Nathaniel stood motionless long after the doctor rode away.

That afternoon, Evelyn helped Grace sit beside the window.

The child watched two horses moving across the pasture.

“Do you like horses?” Evelyn asked.

Grace nodded.

“Papa used to let me ride Daisy.”

“Who’s Daisy?”

“The little brown mare.”

“Perhaps you’ll ride her again.”

Grace smiled faintly.

“Do you think so?”

“I hope so.”

The child leaned against Evelyn.

For a while, they sat quietly.

Then Grace whispered something.

“Mama used to get sick too.”

Evelyn turned.

“Your mother?”

Grace nodded.

“She stayed in bed a lot.”

“Do you remember what made her sick?”

“No.”

Grace looked toward the door.

“Aunt Beatrice gave her medicine.”

Evelyn felt a cold sensation spread through her chest.

“What kind?”

“The same little bottle.”

Evelyn struggled to keep her expression calm.

“Are you certain?”

Grace nodded.

“Only Mama’s bottle had a blue ribbon around it.”

Evelyn held her close.

“Thank you for telling me.”

Grace looked frightened.

“Am I in trouble?”

“No, sweetheart.”

“Promise you won’t tell Aunt Beatrice?”

Evelyn hesitated.

She would not promise secrecy if Grace’s safety depended on telling someone.

“I promise I’ll do my best to keep you safe.”

The child seemed satisfied.

But Evelyn knew she had just heard something important.

The same medicine.

The same symptoms.

Two people in the same household.

And one woman who had cared for them both.

That evening, Nathaniel returned from checking the cattle.

Evelyn was waiting on the porch.

“Grace remembers her mother taking medicine from a bottle like hers.”

Nathaniel stopped.

“She said that?”

“Yes.”

He looked toward the house.

“Eliza was ill before Beatrice moved in permanently.”

Evelyn frowned.

“Was Beatrice visiting?”

“Often. She came every few weeks.”

“Did she bring medicine?”

Nathaniel thought for a long moment.

“I don’t remember.”

“Try.”

He leaned against the railing.

“Eliza used to complain about headaches. Beatrice said she knew a remedy. I remember a bottle.”

Evelyn’s heart sank.

“Was it amber?”

Nathaniel nodded slowly.

“Yes.”

They stood in silence.

Finally, he said, “I need to know what happened to my wife.”

Evelyn reached for his hand.

It was the first time she had touched him without necessity.

He looked down at their joined fingers.

For a moment, the grief in his face softened.

“I should have protected them,” he whispered.

“You can still protect Grace.”

Nathaniel closed his eyes.

Then he nodded.

Late that night, Evelyn woke to the sound of footsteps.

Someone was moving through the hallway.

She sat up.

A door opened.

Then another.

Evelyn slipped out of bed and approached the landing.

Below, Beatrice stood beside the kitchen stove.

A small fire burned beneath an iron pot.

She was feeding papers into the flames.

Evelyn hurried downstairs.

“Beatrice!”

The older woman spun around.

A half-burned envelope fell from her hand.

“What are you doing?” Evelyn demanded.

“Cleaning.”

“At midnight?”

Beatrice reached for another paper.

Evelyn caught her wrist.

“Stop.”

Beatrice pulled away.

“You have no authority over me!”

Nathaniel appeared in the doorway.

“What’s happening?”

Evelyn pointed toward the stove.

“She is burning Eliza’s papers.”

Nathaniel rushed forward.

He seized the remaining bundle before Beatrice could throw it into the fire.

Among the papers was a folded letter.

The handwriting was unmistakably Eliza’s.

Nathaniel opened it.

The first line made his breath catch.

My dearest Nathaniel, if you are reading this, then I have finally found the courage to tell you what I have been afraid to say aloud.

Nathaniel stared at the page.

Beatrice suddenly began to cry.

“Please,” she whispered.

Evelyn had never heard such desperation in her voice.

“Please don’t read that.”

But Nathaniel continued.

And as he reached the final paragraph, the expression on his face changed from grief to disbelief.

Eliza had written:

I am no longer certain that the medicine Beatrice brings is helping me. I have hidden one bottle where she will never think to look.

Nathaniel slowly lowered the letter.

He looked at Beatrice.

“Where is the bottle?”

She shook her head.

“I don’t know what you’re talking about.”

“Don’t lie to me.”

“I was only trying to help my sister!”

“Then why did you burn her letters?”

Beatrice covered her face.

Nathaniel stepped closer.

“Two years ago, I buried my wife believing her illness had taken her from me. Now my daughter is suffering from the same symptoms, and you’re telling me you don’t know anything?”

Beatrice began sobbing.

Evelyn picked up the half-burned envelope from the floor.

There was something written on the back.

A short message in Eliza’s handwriting:

Beneath the loose board beside the old sewing cabinet.

Evelyn looked toward Nathaniel.

“I think we know where to search.”

For the first time, Beatrice stopped crying.

Her expression changed.

And in that instant, Evelyn understood something terrifying.

Beatrice wasn’t afraid of being accused.

She was afraid of what they might find.

END OF PART 2