Pope Leo XIV Never Expected to Become Pope: New Biography Reveals the Private Story Behind His Historic Election

Pope Leo XIV Never Expected to Become Pope: New Biography Reveals the Private Story Behind His Historic Election

Long before he became Pope Leo XIV, Robert Francis Prevost was simply known to many of his closest friends as “Bob” — a humble Augustinian priest who loved his family, valued lifelong friendships and never imagined he would one day lead the Catholic Church.

A new biography titled American Pope: Leo XIV’s Road from the South Side of Chicago to Vatican City, written by NPR journalists Scott Detrow and Daniel Burke, offers a rare look at the personal experiences, relationships and unexpected events that shaped the first American pope.

In an excerpt published by NPR on October 3, 2026, the authors reveal that even as the 2025 papal conclave approached, Prevost did not believe he was a serious candidate. Some of the people closest to him, however, had begun to suspect that his life was about to change dramatically.

His Friends Saw Something He Could Not See in Himself

Following the death of Pope Francis in April 2025, messages of sympathy and encouragement began arriving on Cardinal Prevost’s phone.

Friends from different stages of his life reached out, including John Snider, a Lutheran pastor who had known him for decades.

Snider sent a message expressing support and acknowledging the enormous responsibility Prevost might soon face.

Another longtime friend, John Barry, went even further. He suggested that Prevost could become the next pope and told him that his compassion, intelligence and kindness made him an extraordinary candidate.

Prevost responded in his characteristic manner, saying that he was leaving everything in God’s hands.

Despite the growing speculation, he was not initially considered one of the leading candidates by many observers.

His American nationality was seen as a major obstacle. For centuries, the Catholic Church had never elected a pope from the United States, partly because of the country’s enormous political, economic and military influence.

Even Prevost appeared confident that the cardinals would not choose an American.

After reading an interview in which Chicago Cardinal Blase Cupich suggested such an outcome was unlikely, Prevost reportedly joked to a friend: “I’m sleeping well at night.”

His Brother Prayed That He Would Not Become Pope

One of the most revealing moments in the excerpt involves Prevost’s older brother, John Prevost.

Living in New Lenox, Illinois, John initially dismissed the possibility that his brother could become pope.

But as the conclave approached and reports about Cardinal Prevost’s chances became more serious, he began to reconsider.

After attending Mass at St. Jude, a priest approached him and suggested that his brother’s prospects resembled those of Jorge Bergoglio before the 2013 conclave, when Bergoglio was elected Pope Francis.

The priest even joked that he had considered telling the congregation they were sitting beside the brother of a future pope.

John quickly rejected the idea. He did not want the attention, and more importantly, he did not want to lose the ordinary relationship he had with his brother.

If Robert became pope, family visits and their familiar way of life would never be the same.

John initially prayed that it would not happen. But as his thoughts changed, his prayer took a different direction.

He recalled saying: “Not my will, but, what’s good for the church.”

It was an emotional moment that captured the personal sacrifices that can accompany an unexpected calling.

A Final Meal With His Augustinian Brothers Before the Conclave

The day before the conclave began on May 7, 2025, Prevost visited the Augustinian General Curia in Rome, where he regularly prayed and shared meals with fellow members of his religious order.

He met with Father Alejandro Moral Antón, who had succeeded him as prior general of the Augustinians.

Together, they prayed to the Holy Spirit, asking for guidance as Prevost and the other cardinal electors prepared to enter the Sistine Chapel.

After the prayer, Moral Antón offered him a particularly meaningful reassurance.

He told Prevost that he would always be welcome to return to the Augustinian community for meals, Mass and prayer, regardless of what color clothing he might be wearing.

The remark carried a subtle reference to the possibility that Prevost could emerge from the conclave wearing the white robes of the Pope.

It was a reminder that, whatever happened, he would remain part of the religious family that had shaped his life.

From Chicago’s South Side to the Vatican

The biography traces Prevost’s journey from his childhood in the Chicago area to his years studying at Villanova University, his missionary service in Peru and his eventual rise through the Catholic Church.

Born on September 14, 1955, he grew up in a religious family and developed an interest in the priesthood at a young age.

He graduated from Villanova University in 1977 with a mathematics degree before joining the Order of St. Augustine.

In 1985, he was sent to Peru, where he spent many years serving as a missionary priest and later as a bishop.

His experiences in Latin America became a defining part of his identity and helped shape his understanding of the Church’s mission.

On May 8, 2025, the cardinals elected him the 267th pope of the Catholic Church. He chose the name Leo XIV, making history as the first American and the first Augustinian to become pontiff.

The Man Behind the White Robes

The NPR excerpt offers a different perspective on a figure now recognized around the world.

Before the crowds in St. Peter’s Square, the Vatican responsibilities and the enormous expectations of the papacy, there was a man whose friends could still call him Bob.

His brother worried about losing their ordinary family relationship. His friends encouraged him while he remained uncertain about his future. And his Augustinian brothers reminded him that he would always have a place among them.

The story suggests that Leo’s election was not something he had spent his life pursuing. Rather, it was an unexpected responsibility that he ultimately accepted through faith.

The full biography, American Pope: Leo XIV’s Road from the South Side of Chicago to Vatican City, was written by Scott Detrow and Daniel Burke and published in October 2026.

Source link:  npr.org