The Chicago Neighborhood That Saw Something Special in the Boy Who Became Pope Leo XIV
The Chicago Neighborhood That Saw Something Special in the Boy Who Became Pope Leo XIV
When Robert Francis Prevost was growing up in the Chicago area, few people could have imagined that he would one day become the leader of the Catholic Church. Yet according to a new biography, some people who knew him as a child already believed he was destined for something unusual.
The story is explored in American Pope: Leo XIV’s Road from the South Side of Chicago to Vatican City, written by NPR journalists Scott Detrow and Daniel Burke. The authors spent a year researching Prevost’s life, interviewing hundreds of relatives, friends, teachers, classmates and fellow religious figures.
In an interview about the book, Daniel Burke recalled hearing stories about the young Prevost from people in his neighborhood. Some reportedly described him as a special child and even suggested that he might become pope one day.
Such comments were made long before Prevost had entered the upper levels of the Catholic Church. At that stage, he was a young student growing up in Illinois, developing interests and forming relationships like other children.
His fascination with religion, however, stood out. Burke explained that Prevost enjoyed pretending to be a priest and conducting imaginary Masses for his two brothers. He used Necco wafers as pretend Communion hosts, turning a childhood game into a small imitation of the religious ceremonies he admired.
The book also traces his early education and the experiences that helped shape his intellectual interests. Prevost attended school in the Chicago area and later continued his studies through the Augustinians.
His decision to pursue religious life came at a relatively young age. According to co-author Scott Detrow, Prevost was already considering the priesthood while he was in middle school.
That choice required serious reflection. Becoming a priest meant accepting a life of religious commitment, including celibacy and a dedication to serving the Church. Prevost sometimes discussed the decision with his father, Louis, as he considered whether it was truly the right direction for his future.
His family’s influence remained important as he moved through religious formation. The biography also describes his relationship with his parents and the personal experiences that would later shape his life, including his mother’s illness and his father’s death.
After joining the Augustinian order, Prevost’s path took him far beyond Chicago. He became a missionary in Peru, where he developed close connections with local communities. He later served as Bishop of Chiclayo and became prior general of the worldwide Augustinian order.
His career eventually brought him to the Vatican, where Pope Francis appointed him prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops in 2023. He was created a cardinal that same year.
When the cardinals elected him pope on May 8, 2025, the neighborhood stories took on a new meaning. The boy whom some people remembered as unusually interested in religion had become the first American-born pontiff.
The biography does not suggest that his election was inevitable. In fact, Prevost himself reportedly believed that an American would not be chosen pope. But the recollections of people who knew him during childhood reveal how his interests and character had developed over many years.
For those who remember him before the Vatican, the election represented an extraordinary transformation. For the wider world, the stories offer a more intimate way to understand the man now known as Leo XIV.
Source: Louisville Public Media; NPR; Macmillan Publishers