Pope Leo XIV Says Spiritual Abuse Must Be Addressed Under Church Law as He Signals Need for Clearer Rules

Pope Leo XIV Says Spiritual Abuse Must Be Addressed Under Church Law as He Signals Need for Clearer Rules

ABOARD THE PAPAL PLANE — Pope Leo XIV has acknowledged that spiritual abuse is a serious problem within the Catholic Church and said clearer legal provisions are needed to ensure that allegations can be addressed through a defined system of accountability.

The Pope discussed the issue on November 16 while speaking with journalists aboard his return flight to Rome from Peru. His comments followed meetings with survivors of abuse during his recent visits to Argentina and Peru, where he heard concerns about the suffering experienced by people within Church institutions.

Leo, a canon lawyer by training, said the Church must develop a clearer legal framework for dealing with cases in which priests use their spiritual authority to exploit people under their care.

He explained that justice requires more than recognizing that harmful behavior has occurred. There must also be a legal basis that establishes how misconduct is defined, investigated and punished.

The Pope acknowledged that the concept of spiritual abuse remains difficult to define precisely under existing Church law. He said a clearer juridical expression was necessary so that those responsible could be held accountable through appropriate procedures.

Spiritual abuse can involve the misuse of religious authority to manipulate, control or exploit another person. Because the relationship between a priest and a member of the faithful can involve deep trust, the misuse of that position may cause serious psychological and emotional harm.

In some cases, allegations also involve physical or sexual misconduct. However, the central issue in spiritual abuse is the misuse of a person’s religious influence or authority, which can make it especially difficult for victims to recognize what is happening or seek help.

Leo noted that the Church already has canonical provisions addressing certain forms of sexual abuse, particularly offenses involving minors. But he acknowledged that the legal treatment of spiritual abuse presents a different challenge and requires further attention.

The Pope’s remarks came after he met with survivors during his South American journey. Those meetings were part of a wider effort to listen to people who say they were harmed within Church settings and to recognize the lasting consequences of their experiences.

The issue has remained a source of concern for Catholics around the world, particularly where victims have questioned whether Church authorities responded adequately to complaints or protected those accused of misconduct.

Leo’s comments suggested that he recognizes the importance of establishing clear procedures rather than relying only on general moral statements.

He also acknowledged that people within the Church can identify specific cases or patterns of conduct that raise concerns about spiritual abuse. Yet without a clear legal definition and process, responding consistently can be difficult.

The Pope’s remarks may therefore open the door to further work on the Church’s canonical framework. Any new provisions would need to establish how allegations are assessed, what standards of evidence apply and what consequences may follow when misconduct is proven.

Such changes would also have to consider the rights of those accused, while ensuring that people who report abuse are treated with dignity and are not pressured into silence.

Leo’s position is significant because he has repeatedly described unity and healing as central priorities of his pontificate. His latest comments indicate that reconciliation cannot mean avoiding difficult questions or overlooking wrongdoing.

A Church that seeks to heal divisions must also be willing to confront situations in which authority has been misused. For survivors, meaningful accountability can be an important part of restoring trust and recognizing the harm they have experienced.

The Pope did not announce a completed reform or provide a timetable for new rules. Instead, he identified a legal gap and emphasized the need for a more precise framework.

His remarks point to a difficult task ahead: translating the Church’s recognition of spiritual abuse into procedures capable of delivering justice and preventing further harm.

Source: Associated Press