The Chicago Cardinal Who Made History: How Robert Prevost Became Pope Leo XIV

The Chicago Cardinal Who Made History: How Robert Prevost Became Pope Leo XIV

The election of Pope Leo XIV on May 8, 2025, marked a historic moment for the Catholic Church. When white smoke rose above the Sistine Chapel, announcing that the cardinals had chosen a new successor to Saint Peter, the world soon learned that the man elected was Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost, a Chicago-born missionary who had spent much of his life serving communities in Peru.

His election made him the first pope born in North America and the first member of the Augustinian Order to become leader of the Catholic Church. But behind the historic announcement was a story that stretched across continents, from an American childhood to missionary work in Latin America and senior responsibilities within the Vatican.

The moment the world learned his name

The announcement came on the afternoon of May 8, 2025, in Vatican City. At approximately 6:07 p.m. Rome time, white smoke emerged from the chimney of the Sistine Chapel, signaling that the conclave had reached a decision.

The bells of St. Peter’s Basilica soon began ringing as crowds gathered in the square celebrated the news. Tens of thousands of people had waited for hours, watching the chimney and hoping to discover who would become the next Pope.

French Cardinal Dominique Mamberti, the senior cardinal deacon, appeared on the central balcony of St. Peter’s Basilica at 7:12 p.m. and delivered the traditional announcement: “Habemus Papam” — We have a Pope.

He then announced the name of Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost and the papal name he had chosen: Leo XIV.

About ten minutes later, the new Pope stepped onto the balcony wearing the traditional white papal cassock. He smiled and waved to the crowd as people shouted “Viva il Papa!”

For many observers, the announcement was surprising. Although Prevost had been discussed as a possible successor to Pope Francis, his election still represented a historic development in the Church’s leadership.

A Chicago native with a global background

Robert Francis Prevost was born on September 14, 1955, in Chicago, Illinois. He grew up in a Catholic family and developed an interest in religious life at an early age.

His academic journey began at Villanova University in Pennsylvania, where he earned a bachelor’s degree in mathematics. He later studied theology in Chicago and canon law in Rome before being ordained a priest on June 19, 1982.

Although he was born and educated in the United States, much of his priestly life unfolded elsewhere.

In 1985, Prevost joined an Augustinian mission in Peru. He initially served in Chulucanas before moving to Trujillo, where he worked in pastoral ministry, religious formation and education.

His responsibilities included teaching future priests, helping guide Augustinian communities and serving local parishes. He also worked with communities facing poverty and other social challenges.

These experiences established a lasting connection with Peru. He eventually became a naturalized Peruvian citizen, giving him both American and Peruvian citizenship.

His background made him an unusual figure in the College of Cardinals: an American-born church leader whose professional and pastoral experience was deeply rooted in Latin America.

Twelve years leading the Augustinians

Prevost’s leadership responsibilities expanded significantly in 2001, when he was elected Prior General of the Order of Saint Augustine.

The position placed him at the head of an international religious community with members and institutions across the world. He served two consecutive terms, remaining in the role until 2013.

As Prior General, he traveled extensively and worked with Augustinian communities in different countries. The experience required him to understand different cultural environments while maintaining a shared religious identity among members of the order.

His Augustinian background later became a defining part of his papal identity. During his first address as Pope, he introduced himself as a son of Saint Augustine and quoted the saint’s words: “With you I am a Christian and for you a bishop.”

The quotation reflected a vision of leadership based on service and shared faith rather than distance from ordinary believers.

Pope Francis entrusted him with an important Vatican position

In 2014, Pope Francis appointed Prevost Bishop of Chiclayo in northern Peru. He served there until January 2023, when Francis called him to Rome to become Prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops.

The appointment placed him in a position of considerable influence within the Vatican. The dicastery assists the Pope in matters concerning bishops and plays an important role in evaluating candidates for episcopal appointments.

Prevost’s responsibilities brought him into contact with bishops from many countries and gave him an international perspective on the challenges facing Catholic dioceses.

He also became President of the Pontifical Commission for Latin America, a position connected to the Church’s work across a region containing a large proportion of the world’s Catholics.

Pope Francis created him a cardinal in September 2023. By the time the conclave began in May 2025, Prevost had accumulated years of experience in missionary work, religious leadership and Vatican administration.

His first words focused on peace

When Leo XIV appeared on the balcony following his election, his first words were not a long explanation of his plans or an announcement of new Church policies.

Instead, he greeted the crowd with a familiar Christian expression:

“Peace be with you.”

He explained that these were the first words of the risen Christ to his disciples and expressed his hope that Christ’s peace would enter people’s hearts, families and the whole world.

He described this peace as “unarmed and disarming,” emphasizing humility and perseverance.

The new Pope also spoke about the importance of unity, justice and missionary activity. He said the Church should build bridges, maintain dialogue and remain open to welcoming everyone, particularly those who were suffering.

His address also included a clear reference to the pontificate of Pope Francis. Leo said that God loves everyone unconditionally and encouraged the faithful to continue forward together without fear.

The message established several themes that would become important reference points in his public ministry.

A connection to Peru that remained close to his heart

Although Leo XIV’s election was celebrated as a historic moment in the United States, Peru also had a special reason to celebrate.

The new Pope had spent many years in the country, first as an Augustinian missionary and later as Bishop of Chiclayo. His experiences there shaped his pastoral approach and brought him into contact with people from different social and economic backgrounds.

His connection with Peru was not simply professional. The country had become a second home, and he maintained relationships with communities he had served long before becoming a cardinal.

That connection was visible in his first address as Pope, when he switched to Spanish to greet the people of Chiclayo. He remembered their faith and thanked them for accompanying him during his years as their bishop.

The greeting demonstrated that he had not forgotten the communities that had played such an important role in his life.

His views on Church leadership and unity

Before becoming Pope, Prevost had spoken about the importance of bishops serving as pastors rather than relying on authority or status.

In a 2023 interview with Vatican News, he referred to four forms of closeness associated with Pope Francis: closeness to God, brother bishops, priests and all the people of God.

He warned against bishops becoming isolated from the communities they were called to serve. In his view, authority should be expressed through service, accompaniment and teaching.

He also spoke about the danger of divisions within the Church, describing a lack of unity as a painful wound. He believed bishops had a particular responsibility to encourage communion rather than deepen internal conflicts.

These statements offered additional context for his first address as Pope, in which he called for a missionary and synodal Church that journeys together.

A historic election with a personal story behind it

The election of Leo XIV represented more than the arrival of the first American-born Pope. It brought to the papacy a man whose life had been shaped by several different worlds.

He was born in Chicago, formed through the Augustinian tradition, served as a missionary in Peru, led a worldwide religious order and later became one of the Vatican’s senior officials.

His election also continued the international character of the modern papacy, following Pope Francis, the first pontiff from Latin America.

For Catholics in the United States, his election carried historic significance. For Peruvians, it was also the return of a familiar figure to the center of the global Church.

As Leo XIV began his pontificate, his first greeting offered a concise expression of the direction he hoped to pursue: peace, unity, dialogue and a Church that remains close to those who need it.

The Chicago-born cardinal had become Pope. But the experiences that shaped him — particularly his years among the people of Peru and his life as an Augustinian — remained central to the story of the man now leading the Catholic Church.

Source: United States Conference of Catholic Bishops; Catholic News Service; Vatican News